Place Name: First Place Contestant Name: City College of San Francisco-The Guardsman Entry Title: City College of San Francisco - Column Entry Credit: Renee Bartlett-Webber Judge Comment: The writer selected ambitious subject matter and expresses themself well. Topics are well-researched and interesting to readers, voice is engaging. Of all submissions, this had the best editing and copy-editing. A clear leader in the competition.
Place Name: Second Place Contestant Name: Las Positas College-Express Entry Title: Dad's Rambling Again Entry Credit: Paul George Judge Comment: Love the title of the column "Dad's Rambling Again." This writer has a great knack for scene-setting and delivering thoughtful opinions with creative flair. Some editing and copy-editing mistakes (ie, 'reprise' should have been 'reprieve' in the Taylor Swift article), but an overall really strong column I enjoyed.
Place Name: Third Place Contestant Name: Santa Ana College-el Don Entry Title: Lifestyle column Entry Credit: Danha Sanchez Judge Comment: Two columns full of Santa Ana flavor that local readers would enjoy. The review of the taco truck is short and to-the-point, shaped by the writer's memories of Mexico City street food. The column on the punk show is longer and not as well written, yet it still captures the energy of the show effectively. Also: I hope this contributor also submitted photos to the competition -- the photos accompanying both articles are fantastic and really contributed to the packaging of these columns.
Competition Comment: A difficult competition to judge because of how broad-ranging the submissions were; I ultimately let the criteria of writing quality and reader appeal drive my evaluations. I appreciated the subjects explored (even among the entries that didn't place this time).