Place Name: First Place Contestant Name: The Press Democrat Entry Title: Sleuths or ‘stalkers’? When Sonoma County citizen-activists push public access boundaries Entry Credit: Phil Barber, Alana Minkler Judge Comment: Excellent explanatory reporting of an issue of high interest to local governments and constituents. The well-balanced research, clear writing and effective use of graphics demystified processes that can be difficult to understand. The inviting, readable design in print and online included a smart mix of photos, screenshots, documents, and info boxes to capture the large scope of the requests local governments are receiving. And by including data from outside the Press-Democrat's readership, the reporter was able to show this issue is not isolated to local agencies. Well done!
Place Name: Second Place Contestant Name: Los Angeles Daily News Entry Title: Fentanyl crisis in L.A.'s MacArthur Park Entry Credit: Clara Harter, Sarah Reingewirtz Judge Comment: Strong reporting and excellent photography and design throughout made for a wonderful series documenting an issue of huge community interest. I enjoyed clear segmentation of each installment, with specific focuses on the the addicts, the secondary victims, the people trying to cure the issue, and reaction to the series from politicians. The writing was detailed and colorful without being overdone. Addicts were treated with respect, and the access is a clear indication the journalists worked hard to earn trust from their subjects. The online presentation was good, but could have been improved with more photos not published in print and moving links to other stories in series to the top. Well done.
Place Name: Third Place Contestant Name: The Press Democrat Entry Title: The Death of Patient 19139 Entry Credit: Phil Barber, Kent Porter Judge Comment: This was an enlightening, well-written and well-packaged series. The reporting was balanced and included diverse sources. Readers benefited from smart use of documents to help explain and illustrate the story in print and online.
Place Name: Fourth Place Contestant Name: The Desert Sun Entry Title: Climate change is reshaping the Pacific Crest Trail, and hikers' dreams Entry Credit: Erin Rode, Andy Abeyta Judge Comment: The mainbar was enlightening and well-written, and thoroughly documented the issues affecting the hikers, caretakers and the future of the trail. The sidebar on hikers was enjoyable but not very additive to the overall storyline of the trail's future. I wanted to see more photos of the actual challenges the weather is causing on the trail to help support the detail in the story.
Place Name: Fifth Place Contestant Name: The San Francisco Standard Entry Title: San Francisco Robotaxis Entry Credit: Liz Lindqwister, Kevin Truong, Morgan Ellis, Matthew Kupfer Judge Comment: This was an engaging series on consumer-friendly topics of high interest. Good use of photos, explanatory video and social media throughout the series. The stories were enlightening and reported/recorded in conversational styles, but they were not overly difficult to report.
Competition Comment: The entries were all deserving in their own ways. But the top few showed well-balanced strength in reporting, writing, photography/graphics and presentation. Some other entries were smartly written but lacked images, graphics or info boxes — all of which can elevate good stories to memorable and impactful journalism.