2023 California Journalism Awards - Professional Division

Health Reporting ( Division 3) Back

  • Place Name: First Place
    Contestant Name: The Tribune
    Entry Title: Future of SLO County veteran treatment program in jeopardy: ‘This can’t get drowned out’
    Entry Credit: John Lynch, Sara Kassabian
    Judge Comment: This drumbeat of coverage about a little-known policy shift at Veterans Affairs showed its immediate impact on a vulnerable group of Central Coast military veterans and one of the lone treatment facilities available to them. The package of stories put those veterans and the affected facility front and center, and then clearly explained the bureaucratic impasse while pushing for answers and accountability. At the end of the series, I was left wondering what has come from the negotiations involving Rep. Carbajal, the VA and other officials. Kudos to the John Lynch, Sara Kassabian and The Tribune for following the many threads of this story and showing the broader fallout.
  • Place Name: Second Place
    Contestant Name: Ventura County Star
    Entry Title: Ventura County hospitals need nurses, but would-be workers can't get into school
    Entry Credit: Tom Kisken
    Judge Comment: The shortage of health care workers is a national crisis, especially coming out of the pandemic. This story examined one of key contributing factors: the breakdown in nursing schools. In Ventura County, they can't recruit sufficient teachers or pay them enough to stick around, and as a result, they need to turn away dozens if not hundreds of qualified nursing candidates every year. The story notes the compounding job vacancy problems in local hospitals and health care facilities. And it shows the extraordinary lengths a determined candidate must go through to become one of the few admitted students. This alarming problem for Ventura County and its surroundings is likely a nationwide dilemma, and the findings should prove cause for action among health care and government leaders. Job well done by Tom Kisken and the Ventura County Star team.
  • Place Name: Third Place
    Contestant Name: The Tribune
    Entry Title: How SLO mom beat breast cancer and became an advocate for Latinas: ‘I can give them hope’
    Entry Credit: Sara Kassabian
    Judge Comment: This blended approach to a story of one woman's journey through breast cancer diagnosis, treatment and into patient advocacy was engrossing. In spotlighting an immigrant mother, it elevated the voice and perspective of a patient not often profiled in many stories about cancer, and especially breast cancer. The reporting also highlighted the health care gaps that too often face women of color, including Latinas. Mrs. Olsen's story brought home the very unique and personal heartbreak of such a grave health crisis while also showing the community she relied on to rally her to recovery. This story is sure to have resonated with The Tribune's audience, and it was exemplary choice for the paper's bid to give greater attention to underrepresented communities. Keep it up.
  • Place Name: Fourth Place
    Contestant Name: Ventura County Star
    Entry Title: Camarillo mother's tragic end to help mentally ill son
    Entry Credit: Kathleen Wilson
    Judge Comment: The institutional failures highlighted by this story of legal crossfire over a mother's all-too-avoidable death at the hands of her troubled son were maddening. Huge credit to Kathleen Wilson for weaving the mother's heartbreaking story through high-stakes wrangling that followed her death. This story is one of two submitted by the VC Star that show why it so important to have reporters at the local courthouse. The questions raised here should fuel action to safeguard other family members in similar situations.
  • Place Name: Fifth Place
    Contestant Name: Ventura County Star
    Entry Title: Los Robles pays $30.5M in settlement intended to stay confidential
    Entry Credit: Tom Kisken
    Judge Comment: Secret settlements reached by powerful institutions to make big problems go away happen more than we know. Tom Kisken uncovered one here that pointed to serious shortfalls at one of the community's biggest health care providers. Those lapses lined up with staffing complaints and other findings by regulators. And no surprise, hospital officials defended all decisions while cloaking their response with claims of confidentiality. More to be done on this case and the alarms it raised, for sure.
  • Competition Comment: None